Her First Buyer’s Loan Fell Apart Five Days Before Closing. On the Second Round, Holly Had to Choose Between Cash and Conventional.
How We Sold Holly’s Studio Condo at The Ellington on Broadway, Plaza Westport, Kansas City: The Full Story

Should You Take a Cash Offer or a Conventional Offer on a Condo? Here Is How Holly Decided After Her First Sale Fell Through
Holly weighed which offer was most likely to close, not only which one looked strongest on paper. In September 2026 she sold her studio condo at The Ellington on Broadway, in the Plaza Westport area of Kansas City, Missouri, to a cash buyer. Her first contract had passed inspection and appraisal, then fell apart five days before closing when the buyer’s financing fell through. When the condo drew multiple offers again, Holly chose a cash offer over a conventional one. Casey Kempter of Nelson Home Group, Keller Williams KC North represented her, and the sale closed eight days after the second contract was signed, with no seller concessions. The condo sold below its list price.
A condo she did not have to sell, a deal that died after every inspection box was checked, and a second round where the real question was which offer would make it to the closing table. That was the setup.
Here is how it actually went, start to finish.
The Full Story
Holly owned a studio condo at The Ellington on Broadway, a 1933 all-brick building in Plaza Westport, the stretch of Kansas City between the Country Club Plaza and Old Westport. She did not stay there often, but she enjoyed the condo the entire time she owned it, and she liked the Plaza area. She did not need to sell. She was willing to let it go so she could travel more.
She listed it with Casey Kempter in June 2026. The listing accepted cash or conventional financing, and the condo drew multiple offers right away. Holly accepted an offer from a buyer whose financing looked strong.
That contract cleared the two steps sellers usually worry about most. The inspection passed. The appraisal passed. Then, five days before closing, the buyer’s financing fell through. The reason was never confirmed to Holly’s side, and the contract was terminated.
“Inspection passed, appraisal passed, and five days out the loan still fell apart. After that, the question on the next offer was which one would actually close.”
The Strategy
Casey put the condo back on the market and told buyers plainly what had happened: the previous contract terminated because the buyer’s financing fell through, at no fault of the seller. Showing interest picked up again, and about two and a half weeks later the condo drew multiple offers for the second time.
Two of them were serious, and they were the two kinds of offer this listing could realistically get: one cash, one conventional. A conventional loan on a condo depends on the lender approving the building as well as the buyer, which is the kind of review our breakdown of Fannie Mae’s condo rules for Kansas City buyers and sellers walks through. A cash buyer has no loan to approve.

Holly had already watched one financed deal fail after it passed inspection and appraisal. She chose the cash offer. In her reasoning, as Casey describes it, cash made more sense: a quicker closing, fewer conditions, and an easier sale to complete, especially on a condo.
The second contract was signed on August 27, 2026, and there was nothing left to wait on but the closing itself.
“She had already lost one deal at the finish line. The cash offer meant there was no loan left to fall through.”
The Success
Holly’s condo closed on September 4, 2026, to the cash buyer, 8 days after the second contract was signed, with no seller concessions. It spent 50 days on the market across both rounds, and the whole sale ran 74 days from listing to closing.
Her goal was to let the condo go and be free to travel, and the sale she got was finished and final. The tradeoffs were real: the condo sold below its list price, and the failed first contract added weeks she had not planned on.
What a condo seller can take from this: when a sale falls through late, compare the next offers on how likely each one is to close, alongside the price. On a condo, the buyer’s loan depends on the building too, so ask how the buyer is paying and how far along their financing really is. This was one seller’s choice. A conventional offer can close just fine, and the right answer depends on your timeline, your building and what matters most to you.
Thinking about selling a condo near the Plaza or downtown and want to know which buyers can actually finance it before you list? Call or text 816-680-6624, or reach the team here.
About This Property
The condo is a renovated studio with one full bath in The Ellington on Broadway, a 1933 all-brick building where the HOA covers building maintenance, property insurance, lawn care, snow removal and trash. It sold partially furnished, and the building allows dogs. See the full listing page for 4528 Broadway Boulevard Unit 1N →
For recent sales and market activity across the city, see our Kansas City, MO community page.
Living in Plaza Westport

The Ellington sits a few blocks from the fare-free KC Streetcar extension and about a block from Saint Luke’s Hospital of Kansas City, with the Country Club Plaza’s shops and restaurants and the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art close by. Our Living In: Kansas City, MO guide covers the rest of the city.
Buying near the Plaza instead? Here is who we recommend for a condo near the Country Club Plaza.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a condo sale fall through after the inspection and appraisal?
Yes. A buyer’s financing can still fall apart after both pass. Holly’s first contract on her studio condo at The Ellington on Broadway in Kansas City passed inspection and appraisal, then the buyer’s financing fell through five days before closing. When that happens, your contract’s terms decide what comes next, so talk with your agent, and with a real estate attorney about your contract rights. Nelson Home Group is not a law firm.
Should I take a cash offer or a conventional offer on my condo?
Compare how likely each offer is to close, not only the price. A cash offer has no loan to approve. A conventional offer depends on the buyer’s lender approving both the buyer and the condo building. After her first buyer’s financing fell through, Holly chose cash, and her Kansas City condo closed eight days after the contract was signed. A conventional offer can close just fine; check tax or financial questions with your own advisor.
Will buyers avoid my condo after a sale falls through?
Not necessarily, especially when buyers know why. When Holly’s condo went back on the market, the listing said the previous contract ended because the buyer’s financing fell through, at no fault of the seller. Showing interest picked up again, and about two and a half weeks later the condo drew multiple offers.
Joe Nelson · Nelson Home Group · 1508 NW Vivion Rd #205, Kansas City, MO 64118 · 816-680-6624
Brokerage: Keller Williams KC North · 816-452-4200
The Result
Sold and Closed After the First Buyer’s Loan Fell Through
Cash · 50 days on market · closed Sep 4, 2026
The Ellington on Broadway · Plaza Westport, Kansas City, MO
Sold below list to a cash buyer after a second round of multiple offers. Closed 8 days after contract, no seller concessions.

How the Timeline Ran
- Jun 22, 2026: listed, multiple offers right away
- Jul 12, 2026: under contract with a financed buyer
- Inspection and appraisal both passed
- Five days before closing: the buyer’s financing fell through
- Back on the market; showings picked up again
- Aug 27, 2026: second contract, cash
- Sep 4, 2026: closed
50 days on market · 8 days contract to close · 74 days listing to close.

Her Two Offers on the Second Round
- Cash: no loan to approve, a quicker closing, fewer conditions
- Conventional: the buyer’s lender has to approve the buyer and the condo building before closing
After one financed deal failed five days out, she chose cash.

Before You Pick Between Cash and Conventional
- Ask a cash buyer for proof of funds
- Ask a financed buyer’s lender whether the building has been reviewed
- Compare closing dates, not just prices
- Read each offer’s contingencies and deadlines
- Decide what a second failed contract would cost you
The best offer is the one that gets you to the closing table.

When Your Condo Comes Back on the Market
- Say plainly why the last contract ended
- Make clear when the cause was the buyer’s financing
- Keep showings easy to schedule
- Ask every new buyer how they are paying
A late failure is a setback, not a verdict on the condo.

The Condo at a Glance
- Renovated studio · 1 full bath
- 1933 all-brick building
- HOA covers maintenance, insurance, lawn, snow, trash
- Dogs allowed · rentals of 30 days or longer allowed
- Sold partially furnished
- Cash · closed Sep 4, 2026
Listing side; Nelson Home Group represented the seller.

About Casey Kempter
Casey Kempter is a Realtor with Nelson Home Group, Keller Williams KC North. He lives in a downtown Kansas City condo himself, and condos, townhomes and lofts are his specialty. Read Casey’s full bio →
More Stories Like This One
- A Midtown bungalow that closed for cash after the first buyer could not: Shy Sorden, seller side, Kansas City, MO
- A Northland seller who relisted after his sale fell through: Joe Nelson, seller side, Kansas City, MO
- A veteran couple whose VA loan depended on the condo building: Casey Kempter, buyer side, Kansas City, MO
Two more sales that recovered from a failed contract, and one more condo where the building decided the financing.
Selling a Condo?
Tell us about your building and your timeline. We will walk through who can realistically buy it and how. Call or text 816-680-6624.